Comparing to O's

[Deleted]

Everyone compare roster to Orioles. All 19 starting positions, and bench if you'd like. Name what you're comparing.

Phillies vs. O's

C: Hundley vs. Salt and Yadier: O's win (0-1)
1B: Garret Jones vs. Trumbo/Pena: O's win (0-2)
2B: Neil Walker vs. Kendrick: O's win (0-3)
3B: Youkilis vs. Valencia: Phillies win (1-3)
SS: Pastornicky vs. Asdrubal: O's win (1-4)
LF: Josh Hamilton vs. Morrison: Phillies win (2-4)
CF: CarGo vs. Nyjer Morgan: Phillies win (3-4)
RF: Werth vs. Parra: Phillies win (4-4)
UTIL: Bernadina/Heisey vs. Prado(?): O's win (4-5)

SP1: Shaun Marcum vs. Hiroki Kuroda: Phillies win (5-5)
SP2: Tim Hudson vs. Phil Humber: Phillies win (6-5)
SP3: Vance Worley vs. Jonathan Sanchez: Phillies win (7-5)
SP4: Roy Oswalt vs. Rick Porcello: Phillies win (8-5)
SP5: Randy Wolf vs. Edwin Jackson: Phillies win (9-5)

CP: Craig Kimbrel vs. Marmol: Phillies win (10-5)
CP/RP: Koji Uehara vs. Chris Perez: O's win (10-6)
RP1: Mike Adams vs. Tyler Clippard: Phillies win (11-6)
RP2: Sean Marshall vs. Aaron Crow: Phillies win (12-6)
RP3: Fernando Salas vs. David Hernandez: Phillies win (13-6)

BENCH: O's win (13-7)

[Tigers GM (Alex)]

Tigers wins everything... Rawr.

[White Sox GM (Michael)]

Orioles vs. White Sox

Comparing overall state-of-the-franchise...so it should be who would you rather have now and for the future

C: Molina vs Montero
1B: Trumbo vs Lind
2B: Kendrick vs Zobrist
3B: Valencia vs Polanco
SS: Cabrera vs Castro
LF: Morrison vs Willingham
CF: Morgan vs Revere
RF: Parra vs Pence
UTIL: Peña vs Stanton

SP: Jackson vs Cain
SP: Sanchez vs Shields
SP: Kuroda vs Bumgarner
SP: Humber vs Gonzalez
SP: Colon vs Capuano

RP: Marmol vs Axford
RP: Perez vs Jansen
RP: Clippard vs Robertson
RP: Crow vs Belisle
RP: Oliver vs ---

Bench:

J. Molina, Saltalamacchia, Prado, Bloomquist, Desmond, Santiago

vs

Kipnis, Nuñez, De Aza, Blanco

I'll let you guys decide, or at least have a hand in it. I'll make my picks later. Try to not just go by positional comparisons, because some are more lopsided than others.

[Deleted]

compare to this roster guys adjust everything that changed phillies:
C- yadier molina
1B- Mark Trumbo
2B- Sir Howard Kendrick $16
3B- Danny Valencia-$1m(3)
SS-Asdrubal Cabrera $.5


OF:

RF- Garardo Parra - $1M (3)
CF- Nyjer Morgan-$1.8(5)
LF- Logan Morrison - $1M (3)
Utility LF/RF- Pena
Total-


Bench:


C-Jose Molina-$1.5
C-Salt
OF-Martin Prado-$1(5)
2B/OF: Willie Bloomquist $3.5
SS- Ian Desmond $1(3)
SS: Ramon Santiago: $2
1B- Pena

Pitching-

Starters:

SP- Edwin Jackson $1(6)
SP- Kuroda
SP-Jonothan Sanchez
SP- Humber
SP- Colon


Relief:

Carlos Marmol $7m 2013
Chris Perez $1.8 (4)
Aaron Crow $.5(2)
Tyler Clippard $2.4m (4)(astros is paying 3$ for the next 2 years)
Darren Oliver

Pitching Bench:
SP: Ryan Dempster 6$
SP:Rick Porcello
RP:Hernandez

[Deleted]

C: Doumit vs. Molina O's (1-0)
1B: Morse vs. Trumbo Angels (1-1)
2B: Utley vs. Kendrick Angels (2-1)
3B: Beltre vs. Valencia Angels (3-1)
SS: Tulo vs. Cabrera Angels (4-1)
LF: Holliday vs. Morrison Angels (5-1)
CF: Kemp vs. Morgan Angels (6-1)
RF: Viciedo vs. Parra Angels (7-1)
DH: Bruce vs. Pena Angels (8-1)

SP: Kennedy vs. Jackson Angels (9-1)
SP: Hanson vs. Sanchez Angels (10-1)
SP: Carpenter vs. Kuroda Angels (11-1)
SP: Lohse vs. Humber Angels (12-1)
SP: Liriano vs. Colon Angels (13-1)

RP: Walden vs. Marmol Angels (14-1)
RP: Cordero vs. Perez O's (14-2)
RP: Soriano vs. Clippard O's (14-3)
RP: Lindstrom vs. Crow Angels (15-3)
RP: Oliver vs. MacDougal Angels (16-3)

Bench: O's (16-4)

Final: Angels: 16 O's: 4

[Deleted]

y the hell is bench 1?? position? its should be like the normal cats divided by 2

[Deleted]

Phillies vs. O's(MY OPINTION)

C: Hundley vs. Salt and Yadier: O's win (0-1)
1B: Garret Jones vs. Trumbo/Pena: O's win (0-2)
2B: Neil Walker vs. Kendrick: O's win (0-3)
3B: Youkilis vs. Valencia: Phillies win (1-3)
SS: Pastornicky vs. Asdrubal: O's win (1-4)
LF: Josh Hamilton vs. Morrison: Phillies win (2-4)
CF: CarGo vs. Nyjer Morgan: Phillies win (3-4)
RF: Werth vs. Parra: Phillies win (4-4)
UTIL: Bernadina/Heisey vs. Prado(?): O's win (4-5)

SP1: Shaun Marcum vs. Hiroki Kuroda: O's win (4-6)(gap in ERA is main difference)
SP2: Tim Hudson vs. Phil Humber: Phillies win (5-6)
SP3: Vance Worley vs. Jonathan Sanchez: Phillies win (6-6)
SP4: Roy Oswalt vs. Rick Porcello: Phillies win (7-6)
SP5: Randy Wolf vs. Edwin Jackson: Phillies win (8-6)

CP: Craig Kimbrel vs. Marmol: Phillies win (9-6)
CP/RP: Koji Uehara vs. Chris Perez: O's win (9-7)
RP1: Mike Adams vs. Tyler Clippard: O's win (9-8)(much better k's and better whip)
RP2: Sean Marshall vs. Aaron Crow: Phillies win (10-8)
RP3: Fernando Salas vs. David Hernandez: Phillies win (11-8)

Bench i sweep in at every position so therefore it would be about a tie

[Deleted]

O'ss vs White Sox (MY OPINION)
C: Molina vs Montero o's (proven, and montero in a poor lineup and pitchers park)
1B: Trumbo vs Lind tie
2B: Kendrick vs Zobrist W
3B: Valencia vs Polanco o's
SS: Cabrera vs Castro W
LF: Morrison vs Willingham W
CF: Morgan vs Revere tie
RF: Parra vs Pence W
UTIL: Peña vs Stanton W

SP: Jackson vs Cain W
SP: Sanchez vs Shields W
SP: Kuroda vs Bumgarner tie
SP: Humber vs Gonzalez W
SP: Colon vs Capuano o's

RP: Marmol vs Axford W
RP: Perez vs Jansen O's
RP: Clippard vs Robertson tie
RP: Crow vs Belisle O's
RP: Oliver vs --- O's

Bench: O's(1 point difference)

J. Molina, Saltalamacchia, Prado, Bloomquist, Desmond, Santiago

vs

Kipnis, Nuñez, De Aza, Blanco

Final Score: 9:7 SOX

[Deleted]

Feb 17, 2012 16:09:49 GMT -5 @holaadios321 said:

Phillies vs. O's(MY OPINTION)

C: Hundley vs. Salt and Yadier: O's win (0-1)
1B: Garret Jones vs. Trumbo/Pena: O's win (0-2)
2B: Neil Walker vs. Kendrick: O's win (0-3)
3B: Youkilis vs. Valencia: Phillies win (1-3)
SS: Pastornicky vs. Asdrubal: O's win (1-4)
LF: Josh Hamilton vs. Morrison: Phillies win (2-4)
CF: CarGo vs. Nyjer Morgan: Phillies win (3-4)
RF: Werth vs. Parra: Phillies win (4-4)
UTIL: Bernadina/Heisey vs. Prado(?): O's win (4-5)

SP1: Shaun Marcum vs. Hiroki Kuroda: O's win (4-6)(gap in ERA is main difference)
SP2: Tim Hudson vs. Phil Humber: Phillies win (5-6)
SP3: Vance Worley vs. Jonathan Sanchez: Phillies win (6-6)
SP4: Roy Oswalt vs. Rick Porcello: Phillies win (7-6)
SP5: Randy Wolf vs. Edwin Jackson: Phillies win (8-6)

CP: Craig Kimbrel vs. Marmol: Phillies win (9-6)
CP/RP: Koji Uehara vs. Chris Perez: O's win (9-7)
RP1: Mike Adams vs. Tyler Clippard: O's win (9-8)(much better k's and better whip)
RP2: Sean Marshall vs. Aaron Crow: Phillies win (10-8)
RP3: Fernando Salas vs. David Hernandez: Phillies win (11-8)

Bench i sweep in at every position so therefore it would be about a tie

Mike Adams had a better WHIP. Making bench 3 is a stretch, but it's fine.

[White Sox GM (Michael)]

Kuroda tied with Bum? Especially with that contract? It's which guy you'd rather have, not just talent.

You can have Perez, I'll keep Jansen

[Astros GM (Max)]

Colt .45s VS Orioles

C: M.Montero vs. Y.Molina O's (0-1)
1B: Berk vs. Trumbo .45s (1-1)
2B: Utley vs. Kendrick .45s (2-1)
3B: A-Ram vs. Valencia .45s (3-1)
SS: Pastornicky vs. A.Cabrera O's (3-2)
LF: Dirks vs. Morrison O's (3-3)
CF: Cutch vs. Morgan .45s (4-3)
RF: Heyward vs. Parra .45s (5-3)
DH: Werth vs. Pena .45s (6-3)

SP: Danks vs. Jackson O's (6-4)
SP: Liriano vs. Sanchez O's (6-5)
SP: Dickey vs. Kuroda O's (6-6)
SP: Lowe vs. Humber .45s (7-6)
SP: Matusz vs. Colon O's (7-7)
RP: Hanrahan vs. Marmol .45s (8-7)
RP: Feliz vs. Perez .45s (9-7)
RP: Thornton vs. Clippard O's (9-8)
RP: Mijeres vs. Crow O's (9-9)
RP: Abad vs. MacDougal O's (9-10)

BN: Walker vs J.Molina .45s (10-10)
BN: Choo vs Saltalamacchia .45s (11-10)
BN: R.Lopez vs Prado O's (11-11)
BN: N/A vs Bloomquist N/A (11-11)
BN: N/A vs Desmond N/A (11-11)
BN: N/A vs Santiago N/A (11-11)

So, the final tally, IMO, is 11-11. I didnt count the last 3 bench spots since I dont have anyone.

Max